Crisis is the mother of
innovation in fiscal policy. In the face
of recession when consumer demand is weak, I have long advocated that central
banks make loans to the treasury to employ people and put more spending power
into the economy. After saying they
would never do it, the European Central Bank, is buying the debt of its member
governments. This will relieve the
pressure on countries facing extremely high interest rates on their
borrowing. This enlightened policy is
somewhat offset by the EU governments (led by Germany) insistence on budget
cutting austerity which reduces consumer spending, in exchange for EU bailout money.
Forget bailouts, they would not be needed if the central bank was doing its
job.
The
Japanese central bank is the most progressive buying corporate bonds,
commercial paper, exchange traded funds, and J-Reits. The U.S. Federal Reserve is the least
progressive of the three biggest central banks.
It only buys government bonds. It
says its program will lower long term interest rates. This is a nonsensical objective since rates
are already historically low. Our
problem is not high borrowing costs, but the fact that business does not want
to borrow when consumer demand is low.
Financial
columnist, John Plender, writing in the Financial Times 26 Sep 2012 worries
about central bank balance sheets and the quality of collateral. He does not understand that a central bank
can’t go bankrupt. It can just create
more money via more loans and try again to get the economy moving. A really progressive central bank would buy things
owned by consumers such as home mortgages.
I do not approve of countries such as Greece with overly costly public
employee pensions and early retirement that are unfair to other citizens. But, think what their economies would look
like if pensioners had no money to buy consumer goods. The Greek government could subsidize all
pensions and tell the retirees to go out and buy. Instead, more austerity is being insisted
upon for the Greek, Italian, and Spanish governments. The world’s policy makers and general public
are asking the wrong question when they see rising public debt. The problem is not debt, but how it is
financed. The problem is not the inability of European and US economies to
produce more goods, witness the excess capacity in plant and equipment and
unemployment.